April 22, 2003
Bio. 551 Rec. DNA
Dr. Michelle Mardahl
Topics: Gene Therapy & Viral Vaccines
Gene Therapy Successes and Setbacks
Correcting human disorders in vitro:
Human CF- cells were infected with retroviral vector w/ CFTR- cells expressed protein and had restored channel function
|
Disorder |
Human Gene |
Target cell |
|
Lesch-Nyhan Syndrome- severe retardation, seizures, aggressive and self-destructive hevaior death before age 20 of kidney failure or infection. (orange diaper) |
HGPRT- Hypoxanthin phosphoribosyl-transferase. An enzyme needed to recycle 2 of the 4 types of DNA bases- get uric acid instead |
Human HPRT- cells |
|
Severe combined Immunodeficiency |
Purine nucleoside phosphorylase (PNP) |
PNP- human fibroblasts |
|
Severe combined Immunodeficiency |
Adenosien deaminase (ADA) |
Human ADA- skin fibroblasts, T cells & B cells |
|
Gaucher disease- enlarged liver & spleen, bone degeneration, NS impairment |
Glucocerebrosidase(GC) |
Human GC- skin fibroblasts, bone marrow |
|
Emphysema |
Alpha1 antitrypsin |
|
|
Short Stature |
Growth hormone |
Human liver cells |
|
Familiar hypercholesterolemia (model) |
Low density lipoprotein receptor |
Hyperlipidemic rabbit fibroblasts, hepatocytes |
|
Phenylketornuria |
Phenylalanine hydroxylase |
Mouse hepatoma cells |
|
Citrullinemia |
Argininosuccinate synthetase |
Mouse fibroblasts |
|
Thalassemia |
b-globin |
Mouse fibroblasts, mose erythroleukemia cells |
|
Hemaphilia (model) |
Factor IX |
Hemophilic dog skin fibroblasts |
Animal Models- Genetic Defects have been corrected in Transgenic Mice
Shiverer
- develop trembles and die at youn aged. Offspring are deficient in myelin in the CNS due to a mutated meylin basic protein gene (MBP). Transgenic mice w/ 1 copy- had 8% of normal; Mice with 2 copies of nomral MBP- 26% and were phenotypically normal
Human Gene Therapy
A new age of medicine began in 1990 when gene therapy was used for the first time to treat a young girl with an inherited severe combined immune deficiency (SCID).
Adenosine Deaminase Deficiency- Early Success
Laura Cay Boren- from her birth in July 1982- she fought infection after infection. In 1983 & 194, she received bone marrow transplants from her father- only temp. relieve. By 1985, she was gravely ill. She was injected with ADA-PEG (polyethylene glycol). Within hours- her ADA increase 20 fold. By summer 1988 she could play with other kids.
In 1990, a 4 yr. old girl with ADA-deficient SCID, became the first person treated with gene therapy.
Her own T-cells were collected and transformed with a gene for ADA.
Ornithine Transcarbamylase Deficiency-A Setback
In 1999, gene therapy for OTC deficiency led to a tragic death 18 yr old. patient. The patient died as the result of an unexpected severe immune reaction to the virus used to deliver the OTC gene, four days after treatment. Jesse Gelsinger should not have been included in the study. OTC- X-linked, 1 of 5 enzymes required to break down AA is absent. Nitrogen from AA combins with H to form NH3 ammonia- it accumulates and travels to the brain- usually irreversible coma w/I 72 hour of birth. 50% babies die w/in 1 month 25% die w/in 5 years- control low protein diet and taking drugs to bind ammonia. Jesse was a mosaic, however, he went into a coma after not taking his medications. OTC gene was packaged into an edenovirus (used safely in 25% of 330 gene therapy experiments done on more than 4,000 patients)/ Several billion engineered virus were introduced into a hepatic artery. Autopsy showed organ failute, a previous infection w/ parvovirus led hi immune system to attack the adenovirus, adenovius didnt affect the hepatocytes but macrophage population. This case led to the suspension of several gene therapy trials.
Hemophilia- In 1999 Don Miller was the first patient to receive a disable virus that delivered a functional gene for clotting factor VIII to his bloodstream. He came in 3 infusions one a day for 3 days. As of 2000- there were no side effects. 14 weeks after the treatment he stopped having spontaneous bleeding. 2 nosebleeds stopped within minutes.
The Mechanics of Gene Therapy- Treating & curing the phenotype
Protein-based therapies replace gene products and treat the phenotype.
Gene therapies replace malfunctioning or absent genes.
Germline vs. Somatic Gene Therapy
Germline gene therapy targets gametes or fertilized ova and is heritable.
Somatic gene therapy targets various types of somatic tissue as well as cancer cells and is not heritable.
Gene Therapy Approaches
Ex vivo
gene therapy- removes cells from a patient, manipulates them, and returns them.In situ gene therapy delivers a gene directly to an accessible body part.
In vivo gene therapy delivers the vector into the body.
Chimeraplasty - use small RNA-DNA oligonucleotides to stimulate DNA repair and restore a normal gene sequence.
Sites of Somatic Gene Therapy
1. Stem cells from bone marrow and other tissues are being pursued as sites since under certain conditions they can specialize into a variety of cell types
Bone-marrow- has a drawback in that it is difficult to get high levels of expression in mice studies w/ B-globin gene only 1.3% normal levels. ADA has been more successful- 25% normal levels in mice studies.
2. Endothelium implanted in blood vessels secretes needed proteins into the bloodstream.
3. Skin cells genetically altered in culture, expanded, then grafted onto animals, where they secrete foreign gene products.
4. Muscle - accessible, near a blood supply, and abundant.
Myoblast transfer used to treat Duchenne muscluar distrophy- but did not work. CDNA for DMD is huge- about 14 kb. Requirement to deliver sufficient numbers of myoblasts to all different muscles was difficult and painful.
5. Liver is the largest organ, has many functions and can regenerate. Liver cells from an individual can be removed, genetically altered, and grafted back. Liver cells infected with engineered viruses (Hepatitis) introduced into an artery leading to the liver.
Mouse heapocytes from mice injected with a virus to carry the antitrpysin gene (hAAT or B-glastocises had serum levels after 1 year
6. Lung - use disabled cold viruses to deliver genes
7. Nerve cells- Altered herpes viruses, or treated by genetically engineering fibroblasts or glia around them.
8. Cancer cells are targets for two different approaches of gene therapy.
Suicide gene therapy delivers genes that cause cancer cells to self-destruct.
Cancer vaccines mark tumor cells for destruction by the immune system.
Gene Delivery- Using Vectors
1. Liposomes: Mixture of neutral & cationic lipids in vesicle form. Since DNA delivered via liposomes is usually a plasmid, the DNA remains extra chromosomal.
Advantages:
1. The size of DNA is not limited.
2. The vector can not replicate or recombine to form an infectious agent
Disadvantages:
1. Mode of delivery is inefficient & requires thousands of plasmid copies to be presented to the cell to achieve gene transfer
2. Liposomes may induce a limited inflammatory response.
3. DNA is short-lived w/in the cell and requires repeated doses for continued therapy
4. The effects of repeated exposure are unknown
2. Conjugated DNA- a particle coated w/ DNA delivered directly to target tissue or via blood stream
Particle:
Receptor specific ligands
Example- Peanut allergies cause anaphylactic shock killing approx. 100 people/year.
Animal model- delivered DNA to epithelial gut lining to expose animal to peanuts building immunity. Particle of Arah2 (Principle allergen in peanuts & chitosan (biodgradable component of crustacean shells). The particle protects the DNA delivers it to epithelial cells where gene is expressed. Exposure to small amounts of the protein allowed the animal to develop tolerance to doses of peanuts
3. Viral Vectors- As of 1998, retrovirus, adenovirus, herpesvirus and adeno-associated virus (AAV) vectors have been developed for use in human gene therapy and have reached phase 1 clinical trials. Transgenes may be incorporated into viral vectors by addition or replacement of viral genes. Viral vectors differ in the type of cell they can enter, and in how large a gene they can carry.
Replication competent or helper independent- if transgene replaces viral genes that are non-essential for replication
Replication Dependent- or Helper dependent if transgene replaces an essential viral gene. Gut-less vectors contain just the cis-acting elements required for packaging and genome replication. The advantage is
1) High capacity for foreign DNA
2) No viral gene products are made so has no cytotoxic effects
3) Care to prevent the helper virus to complete its own infection cycle so that only the recombinant vectoris pakacaged.
Retrovirus- RNA virus w/ DNA intermediate. Integrates into the chromosome as a single copy resulting in a permanent modification. Recombinant Retroviruses accomodates ~ 8kb DNA insert
Characteristics-
1. Stable but imprecise integration.
2. Long term expression.
3. Most types infect only dividing cells.
4. Non toxic
5. Often inactivate in vivo
6. Production problems- recombine, rearrange and low titers (10^5-8 pfu/ml)
Applications:
1. Gaucher disease
2. HIV infection
3. Several cancers
4. ADA deficiency
Adenovirus- infects most human cells. Viral DNA integrates at low frequency. Simple life cycle. Infects both replicating & non-replicating cells. High titer- 10^13 pfu/ml
Accomodates up to 7 kb, needs a helper virus to package.
Characteristics:
1. Large virus, carries large genes
2, Evokes immune response- both an antiviral cellular immune response & non-specific inflammation This limits the persistence of the DNA-
3. Transient expression- expression is from weeks-months & needs repeated administration.
APPLICATIONS
1. Cystic fibrosis
2. Hereditary emphysema (lacking alpha1-antitrypsin
Adenoassociated visus (AAV)
Characteristics:
1. Integrates into specific chromosomal sites
2. Long term expression
3. Non toxic
4. Infects dividing and nondividing cells
5. Carries small gene
APPLICATIONS:
1. Cystic fibrosis
2. Sickle cell disease
3. Thalassemias
Herpes virus
Charcteristics:
1. Long-term expression
2. Infects nerve cells
Applications
Brain tumors
Problems w/viral vectors
Viral vectors must pass the human immune system. - Antibodies bind up the virus and can also cause side effects such as inflammation.
Viral particles that make it to target cells face a second obstacle: a tough membrane.
Retroviruses insert the therapeutic gene at a random position in the cell's DNA-might interrupt an important sequence, actually harming the cell or new genes often end up in dormant stretches of DNA where they do not get switched on frequently enough to make much of a difference to the patient.
4. Transposable Elements
Stealth gene As a candidate human gene therapy vector, According to manufacturer, it efficiently and stably integrates genes of any size into the genome of both dividing and non-dividing cells, without causing an immune reaction. Tosk's StealthGene is a patented transposon-based (non-viral) vector that integrates directly into the genome. It is based on the p element vector that has been successfully used for gene delivery in the fruit fly Drosophila for over 15 years. Using the StealthGene gene delivery system to deliver genes to animals is extremely simple, requiring only a standard DNA preparation that can be injected directly into an animal. The desired animals are available to researchers in less than 10 days (compared to at least 2 months for traditional approaches). In addition, the StealthGene gene delivery system works in any mouse or rat strain. StealthGene has worked in every organism tested, including human (cells), chicken (cells), mice, rats, and fish. Tosk collaborators are also currently testing StealthGeneTM in frogs, goats, hamsters, and zebra fish.
University of Minnesota
Gene Therapy Projects
Hyperammonemia- genetically engineer bacteria
Chimoplasty for mutations associated w/ mental retardation
Ex- vivo Lentiviral Stem Cell For MPS
Treating Sickle Cell Disease
With compatible donors, bone marrow transplants have led to complete cures.
Genetically engineered bone marrow
Hydroxyurea to reactivate fetal hemoglobin genes are being applied to sickle cell disease.
Gene Therapy Concerns
Scientific
1. Which cells should be treated?
2. What proportion of the targeted cell population must be corrected to alleviate or halt progression of symptoms
3. Is overexpression of therapeutic gene dangerous
4. Is it dangerous if the engineered gene"escapes" and infiltrates other tissues?
5. How long will the affected cells function?
6. Will the immune system attack the introduced cells?
Bioethical
1. Does the participant in a gene therapy trial truly understand the risks?
2. If a gene therapy is effective, how will recipients be selected, assuming it is expensive at first?
3. Should rare or common disorders be the focus of gene therapy research and clinical trials?
4. What effect should deaths among volunteers have on research efforts?
5. Altering human germline
6. Potential for creating new infectious agents