Soil Ecology and Research Group

last update February 15, 2002

 

ANNUAL REPORT

HABITAT RESTORATION IN SUPPORT OF THE SAN CLEMENTE ISLAND LOGGERHEAD SHRIKE PROGRAM


Introduction

This report describes the activities and accomplishments of the San Clemente Island Native Habitat Restoration Program from May 2000 through January 2002. The goal of this program is to ensure the long-term viability of island species through the restoration of native plant communities, and to increase the understanding that functioning ecosystems ensure the long-term success of SCI Naval operations. These activities have been conducted for the United States Navy, under contract, by the Soil Ecology and Restoration Group (SERG) of San Diego State University. Tasks identified as critical to the success of this program include the establishment and maintenance of a native plant nursery and a seed collection and storage program. Additional contractual obligations include the following tasks:

• Propagation and outplanting of plants essential for the recovery of endangered animals
• Establishment of live reference area/living collection
• Establishment of stock for erosion control, landscaping, beautification
• Propagation and outplanting of endangered plants
• Selection of areas for outplanting, implementation of outplanting efforts, maintenance of records of outplantings
• Provide assistance to other botanical programs on the island such as noxious weed management, herbarium maintenance, and mapping and collecting data about plant populations

Specifically, this report will address progress made on the development of the native plant nursery, progress with native seed collection, the status of shrike habitat enhancements and the progress of a number of lesser projects.

Native Plant Nursery
Prior to arrival of SERG personnel to SCI, development of the nursery site was begun by the Navy Public Works Center under direction of the Natural Resources Office. A site near the Natural Resources Facility at Wilson Cove was selected for the nursery and several improvements were made to the site, including the construction of a concrete work area, storage building and post and cable shadehouse.

During the summer of 2000, early attempts to propagate plants at the new facility showed little success and demonstrated a need for a more controlled environment for propagation. Of particular difficulty were the sustained high winds that rapidly desiccated germination media and buffeted temporary structures beyond utility. A decision was made that a permanent greenhouse was needed to produce the quantity of native plants desired for habitat restoration projects. Funding was secured and the materials for a 24 by 48 foot Agratech greenhouse were purchased and delivered to the island.

In November 2000, ground was broken for the construction of the greenhouse. (Figure 1). A considerable amount of rock was encountered during the digging of the perimeter even with


Figure 1. Ground breaking for greenhouse.


portable power tools, providing valuable insight into the conditions that could be expected for future field plantings. On December 5, 2000, the concrete footings were poured, and the exterior structure was completed March 2001 (Figure 2). Subsequently, work began on constructing propagation benches, work surfaces and the installation of irrigation and electrical systems.

June 11, 2001, marked the first germination in the new greenhouse with the sprouting of Lavatera assurgentiflora glabra seedlings (Figure 3). This species is notable for several reasons. It is a Channel Island endemic known only from San Clemente and Santa Catalina Islands; though it is historically reported as widespread on San Clemente, it is now known from only six locations; and while numbering fewer than 100 individuals, it has no legal protective status.

Currently, there are twenty-three species in propagation at the nursery (Table 1). Most species are being propagated from seed. Seeds are typically germinated in open flats of sterile potting mix and seedlings are transplanted to deep pots containing a mix of native and potting soils. Viable seed has been unavailable for several species that are desirable for restoration plantings. For these species, propagation by vegetative cuttings is being pursued. The chaparral shrub Malosma laurina is an example of a species for which viable seed has not been discovered during the last two collection years. Vegetative propagation is showing success for this species (Figure 4).



Figure 2. Completed greenhouse.


Figure 3. First plant germinated at the new greenhouse, Lavatera assurgentifolia glabra.


Table 1.

Species currently in propagation and approximate numbers produced

Species
Artemisa californica
Artemisia nesiotica
Brickellia californica
Ceanothus megacarpus
Coreopsis gigantea
Encelia californica
Epilobium canum
Eriogonum giganteum
Eriophyllum nevinii
Galvezia speciosa
Hazardia cana
Heteromeles arbutifolia
Isocoma menziesii
Isomeris arborea
Lavatera assurgentiflora glabra
Lotus argophyllus argenteus
Lycium californicum
Malosma laurina
Nassella pulchra
Prunus lyonii
Quercus tomentella
Rhus integrifolia
Stephanomeria blairii
Numbers produced
341
N/A
72
82
52
197
16
149
196
19
297
706
218
286
206
3
23
17
684
429
460
169
109


Figure 4. Malosma laurina rooted cutting.


Seed Collection and Processing
Seed collection began in May 2000 and has been an ongoing task. Target plant populations are monitored for optimum timing and opportunistic collections are made during the course of all field work (Figures 5 & 6). Efforts are made to collect seed from diverse populations. Typically, geographical coordinates for each collection site are recorded using a GPS receiver. A computer database is maintained for reference.

Seed from 43 native species has been collected from approximately 170 sites throughout the island (Appendix. A). Two collections of particular note were made during this period. On May 29, 2000, a collection of Coreopsis gigantea was made near Point Jack. This collection is notable, as the status of this plant population was unknown and thought to be possibly extirpated. This proved not to be the case, as a large population of at least 1000 plants of this species were found in full fruit at this site on the eastern escarpment. On 22 October 2000, collection of Quercus tomentella from one of the Vista Canyon groves yielded approximately eighteen kilograms of acorns. This collection was particularly valuable as no groves in 2001 produced more than a handful of acorns.

Figure 5. Collection of Ceanothus megacarpus megacarpus from China Canyon.

Figure 6. Collected seed of Rhus integrifolia prior to storage.

Collected seed is cleaned and stored in refrigerators at the nursery. Seeds with pulpy fruits, such as Prunus lyonii, are stripped of the fleshy parts before storage to reduce the risk of mold formation. For smaller seeds, an Oregon seed blower is utilized for separating seed from chaff and other impurities. A second refrigerator was acquired in 2001 to increase cold storage volume to approximately forty cubic feet. Refrigerators are kept at approximately forty degrees Fahrenheit. Viability tests are being conducted on seed lots and this information will be available in the future.

Native Species Plantings
Two types of plantings have been undertaken and are ongoing; establishment of a live collection, and outplantings for the restoration of native habitat. Live collection plantings are being made at the nursery and adjacent to the NRO facility (Figure 7) and consist of all species currently in propagation. Species planted to date include: Artemisa californica, Coreopsis gigantea, Encelia californica, Eriophyllum nevinii, Hazardia cana, Heteromeles arbutifolia, Isomeris arborea, Lavatera assurgentiflora glabra, Prunus lyonii, Quercus tomentella, and Rhus integrifolia. These plantings provide cutting stock for nursery propagation, a live genetic reference area for rare species, and a place to educate new arrivals to the island about the native flora.

Several habitat restoration projects are also underway and include shrike habitat plantings, oak reforestation, and Lavatera assurgentiflora plantings.

Shrike Habitat
Native shrub cover has been severely reduced by historic grazing practices, and many species that likely had much wider distribution on the island have been reduced to isolated remnant populations. The reduction of shrub cover by feral grazers has resulted in a net loss of available shelter for animal species and an overall decline in habitat diversity. Lanius ludovicianus mearnsi (San Clemente Island loggerhead shrike) requires shrub cover for nesting and roosting sites and for evasion from predators. A general improvement of native plant diversity would also be expected to benefit shrikes by providing increased habitat for prey species. Additional background is described in Shrike Habitat Enhancement Measures (Appendix B).

Five sites were selected for the first series of habitat enhancement plantings. Approximately 1000 native shrubs and 700 native grass plugs will be planted at these sites. On November 29, 2001 the first of these site plantings was begun at Lemon Tank (Figure 8). Temporary irrigation lines were installed and planting holes were dug. Prior to planting, holes were filled with water and allowed to drain (Figure 9). Water was supplied with a 200-gallon polyethylene tank carried in the rear of a pickup truck. Shrub plantings were completed on January 24, 2002. Species planted at the site are represented in Table 2. The approximate locations of these plantings are displayed in Figure 10.


Figure 7. Diagram of a portion of the live collection planted at the NRO Facility.


Figure 8. Shrub planting at Lemon Tank site.

Figure 9. Pre-watering of planting hole at Lemon Tank site.


Table 2.

Plantings at Lemon Tank site.


Artemisa californica
Artemisia nesiotica
Ceanothus megacarpus
Encelia californica
Eriophyllum nevinii
Hazardia cana
Heteromeles arbutifolia
Isocoma menziesii
Isomeris arborea
Malosma laurina
Nassella pulchra
Prunus lyonii
Quercus tomentella
Rhus integrifolia
Stephanomeria blairii
Planted
83
0
13
46
41
9
50
2
45
0
0
28
16
11
10
Proposed
100
40

50
50

35


25
225
10

40



Oak Reforestation
There is currently very little natural recruitment of the Island Oak (Quercus tomentella) on San Clemente. One possible reason for the lack of seedling establishment is soil erosion resulting from past over-grazing by feral goats. Soil erosion can result in a lack of safe sites for germination. To slow continuing erosion and to aid in the rebuilding of soil, oak seedlings will be planted around existing groves. The first of these plantings will be at the Vista grove and will begin in January 2002. Acorns collected from this grove have been germinated and the seedlings are growing at the nursery. Transplanting will occur following winter rains as soil moisture levels rise. Additional sites for oak plantings are currently under consideration and it is expected that the establishment of three new groves will be attempted in 2002. Another consideration for the lack of recruitment is the possible disruption of mycorrhizal associations. To investigate this possibility, soil samples were collected from twelve sites across several plant communities. These samples are being analyzed for mycorrhizae spores. This data is currently being studied and a report will be prepared under separate cover.

Lavatera Outplantings
Another species showing very little natural recruitment is Lavatera assurgentifolia glabra. Historic reports suggest that this species was once widespread on the island. This species is currently under propagation at the nursery. A number of possible outplanting sites are being considered. The first of these sites is east of the landfill and is projected for installation in late January 2002.

Sensitive Species Preservation and Propagation
A sensitive species propagation program is being developed to aid the reproduction of plant species, which for various reasons may currently be suffering reduced reproductive success. The term “sensitive species” is not meant to carry any legal definition in this usage and may include any species for which distribution and/or reproduction is limited. Efforts to begin the propagation and outplanting of endangered species have been slowed by delays in endangered species permit process. Permit applications have been submitted by the Natural Resource Office and are pending approval by the US Fish and Wildlife Service. In the interim, this work has focused on locating plant populations, investigating possible strategies to reduce the "at risk" status of these species and the propagation of plants without legal status (Table 3).

Avian Habitat Enhancement and Restoration
A primary focus of the Habitat Restoration Program is the enhancement of habitat characteristics for the endangered San Clemente Island loggerhead shrike to aid in this species’ overall recovery plan. Methods being utilized to achieve this goal include the replanting of suitable native species (described above), physical alteration of existing conditions (ie. the removal of unwanted vegetation) and the installation of artificial structures to serve as a stop gap during native plant reestablishment. The rationale for these methods is described in Shrike Habitat Enhancement Measures (Appendix B).



Table 3.

Possible risk reduction strategies for sensitive plant species.

SPECIES
Add to
live reference
collection
Propagate
for
outplanting
Long-term
seed
banking
No specific
strategies
identified
Currently
in nursery
propagation

Castilleja grisea

X

Cryptantha traskiae

X
Delphinium variegatum kinkiense X

Lavatera assurgentiflora glabra

X X X

Lithophragma maximum

X

Lotus argophyllus adsurgens

X X

Lotus dendroideus traskiae

X X

Lycium brevipes

X X X

Malacothamnus clementinus

X X

Sibara filifolia

X



Perch Installations
During the period March – June 2001, 474 artificial perches were installed at thirteen proposed release sites (Table 4). Each perch consists of an 8.5 foot length of 3/4 inch electrical metal tubing, to serve as a vertical support, and a 16 inch length of 5/16 inch diameter doweling inserted at the upper end of the tubing to serve as the perch (Figure 11). The tubing and doweling for each perch was cut to length and drilled at the Natural Resources Facility, transported to the release site and assembled prior to installation. Installation involved drilling a one-inch diameter vertical hole approximately 18-24 inches into the ground and inserting the perch to leave approximately six feet of tubing above ground. Holes were drilled with a Hilti TE 55 hammerdrill powered by a Honda 1000 generator (Figure 12).

Materials were transported to most sites by hand carrying with the exceptions of Horton and Burns which received boat delivery and Norton 6 which received helicopter transport piggybacked with a shrike release water delivery (courtesy of the Institute for Wildlife Studies).

Table 4.

Location of perch sites and date installed.

Site
Twin Dams
Box 4
Box 5
Box 1
Middle Ranch 1
Middle Ranch 3
Norton 5
Norton 6
Norton 4
Horton
Burns
Lemon Tank
Warren
Date Installed
10-Feb-01
12-Feb-01
12-Feb-01
24-Feb-01
10-Mar-01
10-Mar-01
31-Mar-01
3-Apr-01
10-Apr-01
27-Apr-01
1-Jun-01
19-Jun-01
27-Jun-01
Total
Number of Perches
14
28
20
36
14
56
20
42
28
56
48
56
56
474



Installation time per perch varied widely from three minutes to twenty minutes depending on the substrate at the individual perch sites. When possible, holes were placed in rock to provide the most stable installation.

For most release sites, perch locations were selected by the shrike research group, with the exceptions of the Horton, Burns and Norton 4 sites. At these sites, perch locations were selected by SERG staff using the previously completed sites as references. Perch locations were selected primarily along canyon rims and on the adjacent plateaus,

Figure 11. San Clemente Island Loggerhead Shrike utilizing artificial perch at Horton release site.

Figure 12. Drilling hole for perch installation at Box 5 release site.

typically within 100 meters of the canyon edge or on the broad slopes surrounding the release cages. The layout of a typical installation is depicted in Figure 13.

During the installation of perches at Middle Ranch 1, a pair of wild shrikes took up residence at the site. In order to mitigate possible confrontations between this pair and the proposed release birds, a decision was made by the Shrike Working Group to reassign this release site to the Norton 4. This change resulted in the installation of fourteen additional perches beyond the 460 originally proposed. Research and data collection on the utility of these perches is being conducted by the Shrike Research Group.


Vegetation Removal
In order to improve bare ground foraging characteristics preferred by shrikes, patches of exotic vegetation and morning glory were removed from release sites. Herbaceous vegetation was cut to ground level with gas-powered string cutters. Thick-stemmed material and morning glory were cut by rigid blade cutters. Approximately 800 square meters of vegetation were removed from eleven 2001 release sites (Table 5). This activity was performed concurrently with perch installation. Plastic tarping was applied to nearly half of these clearings to kill seed and young plants by a process known as solarization (Figure 14). The tarps were removed beginning in mid-July 2001. The tarped areas had a “burnt” appearance (Figure 15). These sites will be monitored through Spring 2002 to determine the effectiveness of this treatment.

Table 5.

Synopsis of vegetation clearings.

Site
Action taken Date completed

Twin Dams Canyon

Clear 50 meters2 of exotic grasses.

10-Feb-01

Box 1

Installed 50 meters2 of tarping

24-Feb-01

Collected plastic tarping.

29 Jul-01

Box 4

Installed 60 meters2 of tarping.

12-Feb-01

Collected plastic tarping.

29 Jul-01

Box 5

Installed 50 meters2 of tarping on first terrace.

12-Feb-01

Collected plastic tarping.

29 Jul-01

Middle Ranch 3

Cleared 50 meters2 of exotic grasses.

10-Mar-01

Norton 6

Cleared twenty patches in morning glory (35 meters2).

3-Apr-01

Cleared 50 meters2 of exotic grasses.

3-Apr-01

Burns Canyon

Installed 70 meters2 of tarping.

1-Jun-01

Horton Canyon

Cleared 70 meters2 of exotic grasses.

27-Apr-01

Norton 5

Cleared 50 meters2 of exotic grasses.

31-Mar-01

Lemon Tank

Installed 75 meters2 of tarping.

19-Jun-01

Cleared fifteen patches in morning glory (26 meters2)

19-Jun-01

Collected plastic tarping.

17-Sep-01

Warren Canyon

Cleared 10 patches in morning glory (17 meters2).

27-Jun-01

Cleared 50 meters2 of exotic grasses.

27-Jun-01

Installed 25 meters2 of tarping

27-Jun-01




Herbarium Management
A herbarium is a collection of plant specimens that have been pressed, dried and stored for reference. Carefully annotated vouchers can be extremely useful for a variety of research purposes as a catalogue of both current and historic plant occurrences. Until recently, the San Clemente Island collection was stored at the old Photo Lab facility. In order to protect this collection and make it useful to researchers, it has been relocated to the new Natural Resources Facility. Two new herbarium cases, (29”x19”x84”) were purchased from Delta Designs and delivered to the Natural Resources Facility on October 18, 2000.

Vouchers were relocated in small groups to allow for freezer treatment of the specimens to reduce the risk of infestation by deleterious organisms. As each group was transferred to the NRO facility, it was stored first for two weeks in a chest freezer, then transferred to a herbarium cabinet. Following the relocation and freezer treatment of specimens, the

Figure 14. Installation of solarization tarping at Box 4 release site.

Figure 15. Removal of tarping showing “burnt” vegetation.

information of each voucher label was entered into a computer database. A summary of

this data is included as Appendix C. The complete database is available in the Botany Lab and is searchable and sortable by each data field (eg. collector name, genus, species, collection location, etc.). All vouchers were processed in this manner.

Using this database as a reference, a list of species not represented in the herbarium has been compiled (Appendix D). With the assistance of Student Conservation Association interns, efforts will be made in 2002 to collect these missing species.

In October 2001, the herbarium freezer failed. As the interior of the freezer warmed and defrosted, several vouchers were dampened and molds formed on the plant surfaces. These vouchers were transferred to a working freezer to kill the molds and are now in the process of rehabilitation. To prevent any similar damage in the future, plastic tubs have been purchased to hold all vouchers when they are placed in the freezer.


Other Tasks and Projects

Compilation of SCI Flora
An additional task recently completed by the botany interns was the completion of a draft flora of island species. This flora is a compilation of published descriptions for each species known from the island. A collection of illustrations is also being compiled. As soon as this work is completed, a printed form of this flora will be available to residents and visitors and should prove useful as a field guide for the identification of San Clemente Island plant species.

Fog Collection
Post-planting irrigation is critical to the success of most restoration plantings. The first sites selected for planting are reasonably accessible by vehicle. This accessibility allows for the transport of irrigation water to the sites. Subsequent planting sites will be less accessible and alternative means of irrigation are being sought. One area of investigation is fog collection. In many arid areas of the world, fog collection is proving to be a viable source of fresh water. From direct observation it would seem that fog provides a considerable portion of the island’s precipitation, but it is as yet an unmeasured quantity. On December 11, 2001, in cooperation with Gerald Estberg PhD., a physicist and meteorologist with the University of San Diego, a fog collection array was installed adjacent to one of the island weather stations. This collector will provide basic data on the timing and moisture availability of fog events. This data will be very useful in determining the practicality of using fog collection as a water source for irrigating restoration plantings.